| Year | Men's Basketball | Men's Cross Country | Men's Soccer | Men's Tennis | Men's Volleyball | ||
| 2020-21 | |||||||
| 2019-20 | Berkeley | SUNY-ESF | Berkeley | --- | --- | ||
| 2018-19 | Berkeley | SUNY-ESF | SUNY-ESF | Webb | --- | ||
| 2017-18 | Berkeley | SUNY-ESF | Albany Pharmacy | Webb | --- | ||
| 2016-17 | Berkeley | SUNY-ESF | SUNY-ESF | Culinary | --- | ||
| 2015-16 | Berkeley | SUNY-ESF | Berkeley | Culinary | --- | ||
| 2014-15 | Berkeley | Yeshiva | Albany Pharmacy | Berkeley | Yeshiva | ||
| 2013-14 | St. Joseph's | Yeshiva | Albany Pharmacy | Pratt | Yeshiva | ||
| 2012-13 | Berkeley | Yeshiva | Berkeley | Pratt | Yeshiva | ||
| 2011-12 | Berkeley | Yeshiva | Albany Pharmacy | Cooper Union | Cooper Union | ||
| 2010-11 | Berkeley | Yeshiva | Berkeley | Cooper Union | Cooper Union | ||
| 2009-10 | St. Joseph's | Cooper Union | Albany Pharmacy |
Cooper Union | Yeshiva | ||
| 2008-09 | Berkeley |
Cooper Union | Albany Pharmacy |
Cooper Union | |||
| 2007-08 | St. Joseph's | Cooper Union | |||||
| 2006-07 | Berkeley | Cooper Union | |||||
| 2005-06 | Berkeley | ||||||
| 2004-05 | Bard |
| Year | Women's Basketball | Women's Cross Country | Women's Soccer | Women's Tennis | Women's Volleyball | Softball | Women's Swimming |
| 2020-21 | |||||||
| 2019-20 | Albany Pharmacy | Albany Pharmacy | SUNY-ESF | --- | King's | --- | --- |
| 2018-19 | Davis | SUNY-ESF | SUNY-ESF | Pratt | New Rochelle | --- | --- |
| 2017-18 | New Rochelle | SUNY-ESF | SUNY-ESF | Pratt | New Rochelle | --- | --- |
| 2016-17 | Albany Pharmacy | Albany Pharmacy | SUNY-ESF | Pratt | New Rochelle | --- | --- |
| 2015-16 | Albany Pharmacy | SUNY-ESF | Albany Pharmacy | Berkeley | New Rochelle | --- | --- |
| 2014-15 | St. Joseph's | Albany Pharmacy | Albany Pharmacy | Pratt | New Rochelle | St. Joseph's | St. Joseph's |
| 2013-14 | New Rochelle | Yeshiva | Albany Pharmacy | Pratt | New Rochelle | St. Joseph's | Sarah Lawrence |
| 2012-13 | St. Joseph's | Culinary | St. Joseph's | Pratt | Sarah Lawrence | St. Joseph's | Sarah Lawrence |
| 2011-12 | Albany Pharmacy | Culinary | Albany Pharmacy | Pratt | Culinary | St. Joseph's | Sarah Lawrence |
| 2010-11 | Albany Pharmacy | Culinary | * Not contested * | Sarah Lawrence | New Rochelle | St. Joseph's | Sarah Lawrence |
| 2009-10 | St. Joseph's | Albany Pharmacy | Medgar Evers | Sarah Lawrence | New Rochelle | St. Joseph's | Sarah Lawrence |
| 2008-09 | St. Elizabeth |
Pratt | Albany Pharmacy |
Sarah Lawrence | St. Joseph's | St. Joseph's | Purchase |
| 2007-08 | Mt. St. Vincent | Pratt | Staten Island | Cooper Union | St. Joseph's | Mt. St. Vincent | |
| 2006-07 | Mt. St. Vincent | Staten Island | Cooper Union | St. Joseph's | Mt. St. Vincent | Sarah Lawrence | |
| 2005-06 | St. Joseph's | St. Joseph's | St. Joseph's | ||||
| 2004-05 | Mt. St. Vincent | St. Joseph's | St. Joseph's |
Invitational Champions denoted in italics.